HOW TO HOST.

Start with one familiar target, its creators, and a willing group.

PREPARE.

For a first session, try 4–10 people and 45 minutes. Name an Owner, a Host, and a note-taker. Choose something specific that the group knows and has some ability to change: a sign-up flow, expense form, or weekly meeting.

  • Define the target. “The seven steps to approve a purchase” works better than “our organization.”
  • Bring evidence. Show the actual form, policy, screenshot, or a short demonstration.
  • Agree on boundaries. The work is on trial. Personal grievances and performance ratings belong elsewhere. Agree what may be recorded or shared before anyone speaks.
  • Prepare an example. Write one light, specific accusation with a willing creator.

KNOW YOUR PART.

Invite the creators beforehand. Explain the target and format; ask for willing participation.

Owner

The person with the greatest stake in the work. Be here for the criticism. Listen with warmth and grace, thank people for difficult truths, and save your response until after the charges. Welcoming a criticism does not mean agreeing with it. Own the decisions and commitments that follow.

Host

Make the room warm, fun, and lively. Welcome people generously, open with a funny accusation, and help others enjoy the performance. Keep the pace moving and give a good joke room to land. Carry that warmth through the hardest criticism and the close. If laughter turns into ridicule, step in. Anyone can pass or ask for a pause.

One person can do both. A separate Host can tend the room while the Owner absorbs the criticism. Hosting can be delegated; accountability cannot.

Everyone

Bring specific observations, give others room, and help test what you introduce. Say what you know, what you believe, and what needs checking. Stay open to correction yourself. Anyone can pass, write instead, or ask for a pause.

Bringing someone else’s criticism

You can bring someone else’s criticism—even a machine’s. You don’t have to agree with it, but you do have to help the room test it. Say what you know and what needs checking. “Someone else said it” doesn’t get you off the hook.

Speaking for someone needs a real reason: an access need, unavoidable absence, or a credible fear of retaliation. Permission alone isn’t enough. They decide what you can say, about this issue, this time. A private gripe isn’t a public position, and “someone said” isn’t “everyone thinks.” The Host can keep a source private while making clear what hasn’t been checked.

More on responsibility for speech in The Dionysus Program ↗

What crosses the line?

The ritual needs trust. Here’s what breaks it:

  • Making it personal: humiliation, scapegoating, or turning someone into the punchline.
  • Punishing someone for speaking up, or using what they shared here against them later. “But it’s true” doesn’t make that okay.
  • Rewriting what happened, inventing agreement, or using the ritual to spring a personal ambush.

Stop and look after whoever got hurt. Name what happened and arrange repair before carrying on. The room can’t forgive on someone else’s behalf. Questioning the ritual or its leaders is fair game. The Owner and Host follow these rules too.

Crimes Against Ren in The Dionysus Program ↗

OPEN TOGETHER.

Today we’re putting [the target] on trial, with its creators here to join in.

Our Owner is [name the Owner], who welcomes the criticism and owns what follows. Our Host is [name the Host], who’ll keep this warm, lively, and on track.

We’re here to find what’s wrong and make it better. We can question anything, including this ritual.

We’ll welcome criticism, look after the people who offer it, and let what we learn change our minds. No humiliation, payback, or scapegoats. If we cause harm, we’ll own it and work to repair it. The Owner and Host make the same commitment.

Can we all commit to that? If something gives you pause, say so before we start.

Keep the criticism on the work. Choose an opening: “It’s so dumb…”, “In a world…”, or another starter from the deck. Exaggerate, but give us something real to examine. Anyone can pass or ask for a pause. We’ll hear the creators after the charges.

Host cue: Hear each person’s answer; silence isn’t a yes. Resolve concerns or pause. Once everyone agrees, say: “The trial begins now.” Then offer your prepared example.

Personalize the scripts ↗

The profession of faith in The Dionysus Program ↗

A 45-MINUTE TRIAL.

TimeStageHost’s job
0–5 minOpen the courtName the roles. Read the profession and hear everyone’s commitment before opening the trial.
5–10 minGather evidenceGive everyone quiet time to write specific accusations.
10–30 minHear the chargesTake one at a time. Keep the heat on the work; interrupt ridicule.
30–35 minHear the creatorsAsk what resonated and what context matters.
35–45 minFind the next stepHelp the Owner choose next steps and who will carry them out. Close the ritual explicitly.

Record observations without debating each one. Give quieter people an opening. For larger groups, use small tables with one target each.

Six ways to start an accusation

Choose an opening and make it specific to your work.

  • “It’s so dumb…” — Comic accusation. Name a specific absurdity in the work and exaggerate it.
  • “In a world…” — Movie announcer. Compare something easy in everyday life with what’s still awkward in this work.
  • “Previously, on…” — TV recap. Flash back to something we said or did, then cut to a present that doesn’t match.
  • “For the low, low price of…” — Infomercial. Sell a small benefit by announcing the ridiculous cost in time, effort, or hoops.
  • “Legend has it…” — Campfire storyteller. Tell the story of an inherited habit whose reason nobody can explain.
  • “Here we observe…” — Nature documentary. Narrate a familiar work ritual as if you’re observing it in the wild.

Try the six templates and examples ↗

Open the host console ↗

CLOSE WELL.

Change gears: “Let’s look at what we learned.” The Owner hears the room and remains accountable for the decisions.

  1. Hear the creators. What felt accurate? What needs context?
  2. Name the issues. Translate accusations into clear problems or questions. Include the quieter observations.
  3. Check the claims. A good joke is a lead, not proof.
  4. Choose one next step. Name who will carry it out and when you’ll check back. Record disagreement honestly; a laugh or silence is not agreement.
From accusation to action“You need onboarding for the onboarding” → newcomers can’t find a starting point → test one welcome page with the next three starters → review in two weeks.

Then close the trial. Out loud.

The trial is closed. Negative is only positive inside this ritual. Now it’s back to things being smart: do the work, test what we learned, and honor our commitments. Save the next accusation for the next trial, where it can do some good. Nothing shared under protection becomes ammunition afterward.

Record the next step ↗

REMOTE & ASYNC.

In person

Arrange the room so people can see each other. Keep the creators among the group. Display the target and record accusations on paper or a shared screen.

Video call

Keep creators visible when practical. Let people post their own written contributions; use the speaking-for-others guidance when someone needs a proxy. Screen-share the toolkit’s presenter view; participants contribute through your call’s chat or out loud.

Async preparation, live trial

Share the target and agreement first. Collect observations in a shared document with clear boundaries on who can read it. People present their own contributions unless they need a proxy.

Fully async

Try a 48-hour thread with a group that knows the ritual. Name an Owner and a Host who will stay present. Post the profession and wait for each person’s agreement before opening charges. State the closing time and timezone. Participants post their own contributions; creators respond alongside them. The Host interrupts breaches and closes with decisions, next steps, and the return to ordinary work.

Fully async is an adaptation to test. Use your existing discussion tool; this site provides scripts and a host workspace, not a shared thread.

TROUBLESHOOTING.

Nobody goes first.

Give people two minutes to write. Offer your prepared example. Invite written contributions. If reluctance continues, choose a smaller target.

An accusation gets personal.

Interrupt: “Keep this on the work.” Protect anyone targeted before returning to the claim. Rewording an attack does not repair harm; if trust has been broken, pause or end the trial and arrange repair.

The creator defends every point.

“Let’s capture that context for the response period.” Correct a false premise when needed, then return to collecting observations.

“Everyone says…”

Ask: “What is the criticism, and how can we examine it?” Separate the claim from the claimed consensus. Clarify what is known without putting the speaker on trial or exposing a confidential source.

The jokes are empty.

Ask: “What did you actually notice? Can you give us an example?”

Someone seems uncomfortable.

Offer a pause without requiring an explanation. Check in privately, narrow the target, or end the session.

One person dominates.

Take one contribution per person, with the option to pass, before opening a second round.

Nothing changes afterward.

Return to the case file. Choose one observation to test, one owner, and a date. Begin the next session with what happened.

Ready to host?

Build a plan for your session.

Open the toolkit ↗